Dave Trott’s Blog

Creative thinking and critique from Dave Trott

ADVERTISING v THE REAL WORLD

Posted in Uncategorized 30 September 2008

Advertising confuses itself with showbiz.

Some people in advertising honestly think of themselves as celebrities,

They believe that what they do is so important they lead the public rather than follow.

In short, some of us believe our own hype.

We believe the world revolves around advertising, rather than that advertising revolves around the world.

We think of everyone and everything only in terms of what we do.

The correct term for this is hubris.

Marion Harper was was the founder of Needham Harper and Steers, a massive Madison Avenue advertising giant in the fifties.

He came into the studio of his agency one day.

It was lunchtime and it was empty, except for one scruffy teenager listening to a transistor radio.

Harper was furious at such behaviour.

He said, “Son, how much do you earn?”

The kid said, “$100 a week.”

Harper pulled out a wad of cash and peeled off $200.

He said, “We don’t allow people to listen to the radio while they’re working. Here’s two weeks money. I want you to leave the agency this minute.”

The kid said, “Okay, sure.”

Then he took his radio and left.

As soon as he’d gone the studio manager appeared.

He said, “Hi Mr. Harper. You didn’t see the Pizza delivery guy around here, did you?”

You might have thought that would be enough to make Marion Harper realise where advertising fits in the real world.

But it seems not.

One morning at about 7.45, he phoned the office to check what time the staff were arriving.  

The phone rang several times before a someone eventually picked it up.

A young man said, “Yeah?”

Marion Harper shouted, “That’s no way to answer the phone you moron.”

The young man said, “Fuck you.”

Marion Harper , “Do you know who this is?”

The young man said, “No”

He said, “This is Marion Harper, Chairman of the agency.”

The young man said, “Okay, do you know who this is?”

Marion Harper said, “No”

The young man said, “Well then, fuck you” and hung up.

 

CHANGE THE RULES

Posted in Uncategorized 29 September 2008

 

When Mohammed Ali was young he was known as Cassius Clay.

He was also known as “The Louisville Lip” because of his arrogance.

He would predict, in rhyme, the round he’d knock his opponents out.

“I’m wise to his tricks,

so he must fall in round six.

But if he talks in jive,

I’ll put him down in five.”

At first everyone laughed at the arrogance of such a loud mouth.

But boxers started to fall in the rounds he predicted.

And pretty soon everyone stopped laughing.

This was something no one had seen before.

A man who was so supremely self-confident it wasn’t even a question of whether he’d win, just what round.

Other boxers were terrified.

The question came to be not, would they lose, but could they survive the round Clay had predicted.

They became so terrified of the accuracy of his predictions, defeat seemed almost inevitable.

His opponents’ confidence evaporated.

They were beaten and demoralised before they started.

Years later he admitted that his early opponents weren’t that impressive.

So, to make himself stand out, he would predict a round to win.

Often he could have knocked them out in the first round.

But he waited, and kept the fight going, until the round he predicted.

Because he knew it would have a greater effect on the better fighters who were watching.

The ones he’d have to fight next.

So he changed the rules of the game.

Frank Lowe did something similar.

As CEO of Collett Dickenson Pearce, he asked Mike Yershon, the head of media, to buy every 48 sheet poster within a mile radius of the agency.

Then he made sure that all CDP’s client’s posters ran on them.

So that any new business client coming in to see CDP would have seen all their advertising before they even got to the agency.

And when Frank Lowe showed them the agency’s work, they were impressed that everything seemed like famous campaigns.

Because, without realising it, they’d just seen everything on posters, on the way there.

Like Cassius Clay, Frank had won the game before it even started.

Creative Pollution

Posted in General, Uncategorized 26 September 2008

When you go to an art gallery, you often see something strange.
You don’t know what to make of it.
Maybe a pile of bricks on the floor.
Maybe a canvas just painted blue.
So you get out the brochure and read what it’s supposed to mean.
Or sometimes there’s even a paragraph printed on the wall next to it.
Telling you what to think about the piece of art.
Because the art itself doesn’t tell you.
It’s inscrutable.
Enigmatic.
You’re supposed to struggle with it.
That’s art.
That’s not what we do.
We don’t do art like that.
Not art like crossword clues that have to be worked out.
What we do has to be self contained and instant.
No one wants to spend time thinking about advertising.
No one goes to an art gallery to look at an exhibition of ads.
No one switches on the TV, laptop, or the radio to browse an omnibus edition of advertising.
No one buys the magazine or newspaper to peruse the ads.
No one walks down the street looking for the posters.
They’re not looking for our ads.
We are something they pass on the way to do something else.
What we do is intrusive.
Or it doesn’t work.
Which is why 90% of advertising doesn’t work.
They assume they have a captive audience.
They assume people are waiting breathlessly to discover what they’re about to bestow on an eagerly waiting public.
Like a movie or an art gallery.
But in fact, it’s exactly the opposite.
To paraphrase John Lennon, “Ads is what happens while you’re busy making other plans.”

Idea v Execution

Posted in General 25 September 2008

John Hegarty says, “A great ad is 80% idea. It’s also 80% execution.”

At the end of the 19th century there were many escapologists.
People who would be locked into seemingly inescapable situations.
They would then free themselves and wait for the applause.

Harry Houdini was different.
He didn’t think it was simply about escaping.
He didn’t even think it was about how difficult the escape was.
He thought it was about how difficult people thought the escape was.

So Houdini made every escape seem as difficult and dangerous as possible.

One particularly famous stunt took place in winter.
New York’s East River was frozen over.
Houdini was chained up.
He was put inside a sack.
The sack was put inside a safe.
And the safe was lowered through a hole in the ice.
The crowd waited.
Nothing happened.
Houdini’s air must be running out.
He must be in trouble.
Surely Houdini can’t survive without breathing.
After 15 minutes they pulled the safe up.
The door was open and Houdini was gone.
He must be dead, at the bottom of the river.

Just as that point Houdini emerged choking and coughing from the hole in the ice.
Unbelievably, he had survived something that would have killed any other human being.
The exploit made Houdini the most famous escapologist in the world.

In truth, he had been free of his chains before the safe was even lowered into the water.
He waited until the water covered the safe, then opened the door.
He hid under the ice for 20 minutes.
Breathing the air in the gap between the water and the layer of ice.
His greatest danger was boredom.
Then, when everyone must think he was dead, he climbed out.
Making as much of a display of near-death as he possibly could.

And it worked.

Of course Houdini was a brilliant escapologist.
But he recognised that a great escape was, “80% idea, but also 80% execution.”

NICKNAMES & MNEMONICS

Posted in Uncategorized 24 September 2008

There used to be a brand of beer called Courage Tavern.

It had some great advertising, done mainly by John Webster.

“Courage Tavern. It’s what your right arm’s for.”

It won lots of awards.

But the brand died because there was no way drinkers could shorten the name.

Research showed that it’s subliminally very important for a drinker to be able to show familiarity with his beer at the bar.

For instance, no one would ask for, “A pint of Double Diamond”.

That would be way too formal.

They’d asked for, “A pint of Diamond.”

Or, “A pint of DD.”

This flags that they’re a regular drinker, and a normal bloke.

But you couldn’t do that with Courage Tavern.

To walk up to the bar and say, “A pint of Courage Tavern” sounded way too middle class.

As if you should add, “My good man” or “Innkeeper” at the end.

No one was going to walk up to the bar and say that.

And you couldn’t shorten it to, “A pint of Tav.”

So the brand died because no one could show familiarity with the name.

So Courage changed the name, from Tavern, to John Courage.

People began asking for, “A pint of JC.”

And sales took off really well.

Even though the brown fizzy liquid was identical.

This shows the power of a mnemonic.

In the mass market, especially amongst men, nicknames are really important.

They show a lack of formality and a willingness to have fun.

In sport, it’s a cliché that you’re not really accepted as one of the lads  until you’ve got a nickname.

Fergy, Keano, Becks, Giggsy, Big Phil, Rafa the Gaffer, Drogs, Lamps.

It’s a way of saying we like you, you’re one of us.

Just look at the Sun.

Nearly 4 million copies sold a day.

Read by 10 to 12 million people.

If they can play with your name, for better or worse, you get much more coverage.

It’s the same in advertising.

If we can find a way to mobilise that natural instinct amongst millions of men, we can use it as free media.

That’s what a mnemonic is.

A way to play with the name in order to get it remembered.

Those that insist on being addressed formally go the way of Courage Tavern.